Ultimate Banana Split Milkshakes

This ultimate banana split milkshake transforms the classic dessert into sippable form, capturing all those nostalgic flavors in a creamy, indulgent treat. I created this recipe when my ice cream parlor craving hit during a heatwave, and it's been our family's favorite summer dessert ever since.

Making these milkshakes has become our Friday night tradition. My children love assembling their own toppings bar and creating personalized versions with extra cherries or chocolate drizzles.

Ingredients

• Ripe bananas: the riper the bananas, the sweeter and more flavorful your milkshake
• Vanilla ice cream: use premium ice cream with real vanilla for the best flavor base
• Milk: adjusts the thickness, whole milk creates the creamiest texture
• Chocolate syrup: provides that classic banana split flavor, use high quality for best results
• Strawberry syrup: adds fruity sweetness, homemade or store bought both work beautifully
• Crushed pineapple: brings tropical tanginess, drain well before using
• Whipped cream: fresh homemade whipped cream elevates the entire experience
• Maraschino cherries: the essential banana split finishing touch
• Chopped nuts: adds texture contrast, toasted nuts provide more flavor dimension
• Sprinkles: purely for fun and visual appeal, choose colorful varieties

Step-by-Step Instructions

Blend the Base:

Place peeled bananas, vanilla ice cream, and milk in a blender. Pulse until completely smooth, about 30 seconds. The consistency should be thick but pourable. If too thick, add an additional tablespoon of milk.

Prepare the Glasses:

Take tall milkshake glasses and drizzle the inside walls with alternating stripes of chocolate and strawberry syrup. Work from top to bottom, allowing some syrup to pool at the bottom. Chill glasses in freezer for 2 minutes to set the syrup.

Pour the Milkshake:

Remove glasses from freezer and carefully pour the banana milkshake mixture into each glass, leaving about an inch of space at the top. The milkshake should create beautiful streaks as it mingles with the syrup lines.

Add Toppings:

Top each milkshake with a generous swirl of whipped cream. Spoon crushed pineapple over the whipped cream. Place a maraschino cherry at the very top center.

Finishing Touches:

Sprinkle with chopped nuts and colorful sprinkles if desired. Serve immediately with a wide straw and long spoon for the full banana split experience.

Pin it

The secret to this recipe is the glass preparation. My grandmother taught me that drizzling the syrups inside creates both visual impact and ensures flavor in every sip. The first time I served these at a family gathering, my uncle declared them better than the banana splits from his favorite ice cream parlor growing up.

Texture Secrets

The ideal banana split milkshake has multiple texture layers that keep each sip interesting. Ensure your banana base is perfectly smooth before pouring. The crushed pineapple should retain some texture rather than being pureed completely. For added dimension, consider freezing banana slices and blending them in rather than using fresh for an extra thick, frosty result. The contrast between silky milkshake, fluffy whipped cream, and crunchy toppings creates the perfect sensory experience.

Pin it

Make-Ahead Options

While milkshakes are best served immediately, you can prepare components ahead of time for quick assembly. Blend the banana base and store in the freezer for up to 3 hours, allowing it to soften slightly before serving. Prepare decorated glasses and store in the refrigerator for up to an hour. Having a topping station ready allows for quick assembly when guests arrive. For parties, consider mini versions served in small glasses as a playful dessert option that can be prepared in batches.

Serving Suggestions

Transform this milkshake into a complete dessert experience by serving alongside crisp waffle cookies or shortbread. For brunch, offer these as a sweet finale alongside fresh fruit and coffee. Create a nostalgic dessert bar with the milkshakes as the centerpiece, surrounded by additional banana split components for guests to customize. During summer gatherings, prepare a batch in a blender and let guests pour their own shakes and select toppings for an interactive dessert experience that everyone will remember.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ How can I make the shake thicker?

To make your milkshake thicker, reduce the amount of milk or add extra vanilla ice cream. You can also freeze the bananas before blending.

→ Can I substitute the syrups?

Yes! You can swap chocolate or strawberry syrups with caramel or butterscotch for a different flavor profile.

→ What are some alternative toppings?

You can use shredded coconut, crushed cookies, or fresh berries as toppings instead of nuts and sprinkles.

→ Can I make it dairy-free?

Yes! Use a plant-based milk alternative, dairy-free ice cream, and skip the whipped cream or opt for a non-dairy version.

→ How can I adjust sweetness?

If you prefer a less sweet milkshake, reduce or omit the syrups, or use unsweetened toppings like dark chocolate or fresh fruit.